They really surprised me. My second order, second mystery pick up, bought 2 wallets. Both really nice franklin 2’s I cannot tell you what is wrong with them… maybe a small blemish like a scuff? And then they threw in a free black leather catch all!

Great quality!

Love the mystery box. Lucked out with a Jackson. Great slim card case. Comfortablly holds 6 cards and 6 bills.

I received my Slim Dutchman in the mail and the quality is excellent. The material they use for the stitching is very high quality. Also, they provide excellent customer service. When I had a question about there products, Olivia was always very responsive! Exceptional customer service.

Picked up a mystery box from Lost Dutchman Leather and honestly, I’m really happy with it. Ended up getting a Huckleberry in brown, a couple of small Finns, and two unbranded ones. All of them feel well-made with nice leather and solid stitching.

The mix was actually perfect—kept a couple for myself and the others are great for gifting family. If you’re into leather wallets and don’t mind a little surprise, the mystery box is definitely worth trying and cheaper.

Took a chance on a mystery wallet. Received the original finnigan. It was perfect for I only carry a few cards with me and some cash. The only reason I can’t give 5 stars is because shipping was painfully slow. After reading other comments on Facebook others were also experiencing shipping issues.

Great product with amazing craftsmanship. I don’t understand if it was a return or a flawed wallet for it to be in the mystery box cause I most certainly can not see any defects anywhere.
Tremendous value

Crazy good deal and was lucky enough to get a preferred colorsway! Excellent handmade wallets.